May 30 2022

Mystery Friday Foto #22 Solved: The Powell Avenue Motor Parkway Bridge in Bethpage under construction circa July/August 1908


Garden City Archives challenged you to identify this weekend's Mystery Foto.

Answers to the Mystery Foto questions:

Identify:

  • The Motor Parkway bridge and the orientation of the photographer.

The Powell Avenue Motor Parkway Bridge in Bethpage. The photographer is looking north.

  • The building on the far left.

The Motor Parkway House on Powell Avenue

  • The approximate date of the Mystery Foto. Provide a rationale.

The Powell Avenue Bridge was completed in time for the 1908 Vanderbilt Cup Race held on October 24, 1908. The likely Mystery Foto date was July/August 1908.

Comments (4)

Congrats and kudos to David Miller, Frank Femenias and Brian McCarthy for identifying the Powell Avenue Motor Parkway Bridge and the Motor Parkway House.

Thumbs-up  to Markus for a good try!

Enjoy,

Howard Kroplick



Close-Ups

Caption under the Mystery Foto.



Comments

May 27 2022 David Miller 12:22 PM

This is the Powell ave bridge in Central Park (today’s Bethpage).  It was classified as a “highway” bridge since the Motor Parkway went under it.  It is one of the original bridges built for the 1908 Vanderbilt cup race, so the photo was probably taken in the summer of 1908.  The photographer is facing north and the building to the left is the “motor parkway house”.  This may have been used as sleeping quarters for the workers.

May 29 2022 frank femenias 10:53 PM

I believe this is 1908 Bethpage looking north at construction of Motor Parkway’s Nibbe farmway bridge (Map below).
The Motor Parkway House was a hotel/Inn once located on Powell Avenue and built during Motor Parkway’s construction in 1908. The hotel aimed to accommodate parkway travelers reaching the mid-point between Fresh Meadows, Queens and Lake Ronkonkoma, Suffolk. I don’t know if the hotel was successful. Nearby was Richard and Ellen Foran’s Hot Dog Stand and Halfway House Tea Room located at intersection of Broadway and Motor Parkway.
Powell Avenue is approx 750ft / 0.14mi from where Nibbe’s bridge once stood. The distance in the photo corresponds. The hotel appears located on the west side of Motor Parkway in the direction towards Broadway.

.https://www.vanderbiltcupraces.com/blog/article/thursday_april_30_2009_the_motor_parkway_house

image
May 30 2022 Markus 8:20 AM

I am by far one of the least qualified people to do this, but I am a history and Vanderbilt enthusiast and I took on the challenge. I am guessing that the photographer is pointing slightly northeast, with the Vanderbilt park slightly to the right. The road going under the bridge would become or already was Springfield Boulevard. The building is probably 223-11 Kingsbury Avenue. Im not sure how to date a photo like this, but from a 1954 aerial photo and when the parkway was built, I would think that this is in 1908.

May 30 2022 Brian D McCarthy 8:53 PM

This is looking north in Central Park/Bethpage NY. Workers are building the LIMP and the future HWY bridge at Powell Ave. This section was ready in September 1908, so maybe this in 1907. That’s the Motor Parkway House to the north & west. Gary Hammond has discovered that a Mathias Romscho managed this building in 1910. I was trying to figure out how long this building resided, but not sure if it was demolished or renovated up until the present. I screenshot 3 maps below.

image image image
May 30 2022 frank femenias 11:38 PM

Much thanks Gary Hammond for clarifying the Motor Parkway House. The bridge under construction should be Nibbe’s farmway bridge, approx 0.14 miles from the hotel, as seen in the photo. If this is the Powell bridge, I’m now confused. What am I missing. HELP!

Leave a Comment